Strature BriefsDecision BriefNo. 022Edition 1.030 Sep 2026
Decision Brief · Canada

The 50% duty, line by line: what it costs, and when Canadian exporters must decide

By 31 December 2026 the duty lasts or widens in futures we put at 70%, eases on some lines in 23%, ends in 7%; each our estimate, scored when it resolves.

For organisations. About two minutes to request; the download link comes by email.

Evidence to 30 September 2026; facts refreshed 30 September 2026.

Exhibit G1 · Decision Brief No. 022
At the end of 2026 the duty lasts or widens in futures worth 70%
Six futures to 31 December 2026, % · our estimates, registered 30 Sep 2026 as F-0156 to F-0161 and scored when they resolve

Dashed line: Even odds · 50%

Lasts · 70%

  • 7% Ends
  • 23% Eases
  • 25.2% Lasts, sales hold
  • 28% Lasts, sales cut
  • 15.4% Lasts, collapse
  • 1.4% Not measured
SourceStrature forecast register, F-0156 to F-0161, registered 30 Sep 2026 and scored when they resolve on 31 Dec 2026; sales measured on Statistics Canada monthly trade.LicenceStrature's own registered estimates.How to read this chartThe accent marks the share the exhibit's title is about; the bar is the whole, 100%.DataDownload the chart data (CSV) q-022-g1.csv
Exhibit G1 · Canada · strature.net

Free to read: the one-page sheet and the executive read

The following applies to this page and to both downloads: General research for general circulation; not investment, legal or tax advice, not tailored to any reader, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Every probability is our estimate, scored when it resolves; to the fullest extent permitted by law Strature accepts no liability (otherwise capped at the fee paid or, if no fee was paid, CAD 100). Full terms in the full brief. Some assets carry sector rules on foreign ownership; we have not assessed them. This notice applies alongside the notices printed in each download.

The notice printed on the sheet

General research for general circulation; not investment, legal or tax advice, not tailored to any reader, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Every probability is our estimate, scored when it resolves; to the fullest extent permitted by law Strature accepts no liability (otherwise capped at the fee paid or, if no fee was paid, CAD 100). Full terms in the full brief.

The notice printed on the executive read

This is general research on public information, published for general circulation to purchasers. It is not investment, legal, tax or accounting advice, is not tailored to any reader, and does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security or loan; options to consider are illustrations, not instructions. Every probability and forecast is our estimate, scored when it resolves, and may prove wrong; the brief is provided "as is", without warranty. To the fullest extent permitted by law Strature and its principal accept no liability of any kind; where a court will not allow that, liability is limited to the fee paid or, if no fee was paid, CAD 100, and indirect or consequential loss is excluded. Strature and its principal hold no position in, and receive no payment from, any company or fund named in this brief. […] The full brief is licensed to its purchaser and the purchaser's professional advisers, in confidence; Ontario law. Full terms in the full brief.

Quoted without one sentence, on how the brief is produced; see the terms for this brief.

Cite this

Strature, Decision Brief No. 022, Edition 1.0, released 2 Oct 2026, https://strature.net/briefs/q-022/

The notices above are quoted as the downloads print them. The terms for this brief, version 1.3 (5 October 2026), apply to this page and to every download on it; where a printed notice states a cap on liability, those terms apply instead: Strature accepts no liability of any kind, to the fullest extent permitted by law.

Strature BriefsDecision BriefNo. 022Edition 1.030 Sep 2026

Evidence to 30 September 2026; facts refreshed 30 September 2026.

Data. Each exhibit’s Download the chart data (CSV) link gives exactly the values drawn in that chart, with its title, source, credit, licence, retrieval date, the brief’s number and our general-research notice in the file’s first lines. It is free to use under the licence stated with it, crediting the source as printed. Deeper datasets come only with the full brief.

In context

The answer in context.

Written for this page by Strature from the brief’s free layers and the forecast register; the answer above is quoted as printed.

The situation

A 50% US duty under Section 338 reaches Canadian goods on listed tariff lines, and since 29 September 2026, 97 of the 1,413 listed lines are banned outright.

What the number means

70% is the sum of four of six scenarios for 31 December 2026 in which the duty has neither ended nor eased: US-bound sales hold (25.2%), are cut (28%), collapse (15.4%) or are not yet measured (1.4%). Partial relief carries 23% and an end to the duty 7%. Each is our estimate, scored when it resolves.

The question, who it is for, how it is decided and key terms

The question

What does the 50% duty cost, line by line, and when must Canadian exporters decide?

Who it is for

Prepared for Canadian exporters on listed US tariff lines, and the lenders who finance them. General circulation.

How it is decided

The forecast register’s own words, quoted as registered; a registered forecast is never edited.

F-0156 · The duty ends · 7% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, an instrument or all-importer court order (after 2026-09-30) ends or suspends collection of the 50% Section 338 duty on products of Canada on every listed line”

F-0157 · Partial relief · 23% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, the Section 338 duty has not ended but an instrument or all-importer court order (after 2026-09-30) lowers or suspends it on a line, lifts or narrows a ban, restores a carve-out, or cuts the listed classifications on net”

F-0158 · Lasts, US-bound sales hold · 25.2% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, the Section 338 duty has not ended or eased and first-published StatCan exports to the US on the fully listed codes (bans excluded) for Sep+Oct 2026 fell by less than 10% y/y, or rose”

F-0159 · Lasts, sales cut · 28% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, the Section 338 duty has not ended or eased and first-published StatCan exports to the US on the fully listed codes (bans excluded) for Sep+Oct 2026 fell by 10% to 33.3% y/y”

F-0160 · Lasts, sales collapse · 15.4% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, the Section 338 duty has not ended or eased and first-published StatCan exports to the US on the fully listed codes (bans excluded) for Sep+Oct 2026 fell by more than 33.3% y/y”

F-0161 · Lasts, sales not yet measured · 1.4% · resolves by 31 Dec 2026

“Resolves if, by 2026-12-31, the Section 338 duty has not ended or eased and StatCan has published neither the September nor the October 2026 merchandise trade month”

Resolves · on the forecast register

Key terms

Listed line
A ten-digit tariff code named on a US list. The duty applies line by line, not to a whole sector.
Banned outright
A listed line excluded from the US market altogether, not charged the duty: 97 of 1,413 lines since 29 September 2026.
What US customers must carry
The share of the duty US buyers would have to pay through higher prices for an exporter's margin to survive with no sales lost: at least 54% to 81% across the five largest listed groups (the brief's calculation).
Decision point
4 November 2026, when September trade data give the first full month after the duty, confirmed on 8 December by the October data.
Live exhibits

The other free exhibits, with their data.

Exhibit L1 · Decision Brief No. 022
Absorbing erases the margin unless US customers carry at least 54 to 81%
Share of the 50% duty US customers must carry, no sales lost · our calculation

Dashed line: Half · 50%

Electrical, at least54.2%
Paper, at least61.5%
Plastics67.4%
Furniture, at least76.3%
Wood, at least80.6%
% of the duty
Absorbing erases the margin unless US customers carry at least 54 to 81%: the data
Item% of the duty
Electrical, at least54.2%
Paper, at least61.5%
Plastics67.4%
Furniture, at least76.3%
Wood, at least80.6%
SourceStrature model; retrieved 30 Sep 2026.CreditAdapted from Statistics Canada, Table 16-10-0117-01, Principal statistics for manufacturing industries, by North American Industry Classification System (NAICS), 2024. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.CreditAdapted from Statistics Canada, Table 33-10-0225-01, Quarterly balance sheet, income statement and selected financial ratios, by non-financial industries, non seasonally adjusted, second quarter 2026. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.LicenceStatistics Canada Open Licence (Tables 16-10-0117-01 and 33-10-0225-01), with Strature's model.How to read this chartThe accent: none. Each bar is read against the dashed line.DataDownload the chart data (CSV) q-022-l1.csv
Exhibit L1 · Canada · strature.net
Exhibit L5 · Decision Brief No. 022
C$6.5bn to C$17.5bn of the five groups' US sales sit on listed lines
2025 US-bound exports on Section 338 listed lines, C$bn · five largest groups · lines surely listed and all that may be

Dashed line: Zero · C$0

Electrical, surely listed0.4bn
Electrical, may be listed4.5bn
Plastics, surely listed2.3bn
Plastics, may be listed3.9bn
Furniture, surely listed2bn
Furniture, may be listed3.8bn
Paper, surely listed0.9bn
Paper, may be listed3.2bn
Wood, surely listed0.9bn
Wood, may be listed2.1bn
C$bn, 2025
C$6.5bn to C$17.5bn of the five groups' US sales sit on listed lines: the data
ItemC$bn, 2025
Electrical, surely listed0.4bn
Electrical, may be listed4.5bn
Plastics, surely listed2.3bn
Plastics, may be listed3.9bn
Furniture, surely listed2bn
Furniture, may be listed3.8bn
Paper, surely listed0.9bn
Paper, may be listed3.2bn
Wood, surely listed0.9bn
Wood, may be listed2.1bn
SourceStatistics Canada CIMT, domestic exports to the US on listed lines, 2025; Strature calculation; retrieved 30 Sep 2026.CreditAdapted from Statistics Canada, Canadian International Merchandise Trade Database, domestic exports to the United States, 2025. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.LicenceStatistics Canada Open Licence (CIMT), with Strature's arithmetic.How to read this chartThe accent: none. Each bar is read against the dashed line.DataDownload the chart data (CSV) q-022-l5.csv
Exhibit L5 · Canada · strature.net
Strature GPS · Questions this brief addresses

16 questions this brief addresses, each on the map.

Each answer is quoted verbatim from the brief, with the section that answers it and the countries it touches. Answers with a register ID are our estimates, scored when they resolve; the others are the brief’s reading of the evidence, not forecasts.

Where this brief sits in GPS

Addressed in: The call (one-page sheet; at a glance)

Geoeconomic

What does the 50% duty cost, line by line, and when must Canadian exporters decide?

“Absorbing the 50% erases margins unless US customers carry at least 54 to 81% with no sales lost; at the mildest loss, 88 to 91%, paper and electrical only (our calculation). Decision point: 4 November, confirmed 8 December.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Geoeconomic · Geopolitical

Will the 50% duty last past 31 December 2026?

“By 31 December 2026 the duty lasts or widens in futures we put at 70%, eases on some lines in 23%, ends in 7%; each our estimate, scored when it resolves.”

On the register: F-0156 7%, open · F-0157 23%, open · F-0158 25%, open · F-0159 28%, open · F-0160 15%, open · F-0161 1%, open. The forecast register

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 01. No US instrument ends or changes the Section 338 duties on 1 January 2027

Geoeconomic · Geopolitical

How long will the duty last?

“No instrument read ends or cuts the Section 338 duty or gives it an end date, which means an exporter could plan on it lasting into 2027.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Show all 16 questions

Addressed in: 04. Exposure to the duty differs line by line, not sector by sector

Geoeconomic · Geopolitical

Which goods are caught, and does origin help?

“Whether the duty bites is decided by the ten-digit tariff line, not by the sector a firm belongs to.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 06. No exporter or US buyer filing yet shows US customers switching suppliers

Geoeconomic

Will US customers pay, or will other markets buy?

“No filing we read shows US customers dropping Canadian suppliers, and every period in them ended before the duty began.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 08. Absorbing erases margins unless customers carry at least 54 to 81% of the duty

Geoeconomic

Hold, redirect or move, and when?

“Absorbing the duty erases the margin in the five largest groups unless US customers carry at least 54 to 81% of it, with no sales lost (our calculation).”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 12. Relief is mostly loans, and a loan can bring a covenant breach forward

Geoeconomic

Who can carry the duty, and what relief comes?

“Most tariff relief must be repaid, and none of it is sized to the US duty.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 02. Each Section 338 change came from Washington, not from the CUSMA review

Geoeconomic · Geopolitical

Did the Section 338 changes come from Washington or from the CUSMA review?

“Every Section 338 instrument so far was a US proclamation or customs bulletin, which means the CUSMA review has not been where an exporter's duty is set.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 03. At IEEPA's pace, a suit filed now would stop collection only after June 2027

Geoeconomic · Geopolitical

Could a court suit stop the duty's collection before June 2027?

“No suit against the Section 338 duty has been found, which means a court exit, at the only pace on record, would stop collection after June 2027.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 05. A US final step avoids the duty only where the crossing input is unlisted

Geoeconomic

Does a US final step avoid the duty?

“Our reading of the published rules, not a customs ruling: a US finishing step leaves the duty in place, because it is charged as the Canadian article crosses.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 07. The US buys 77 to 99% of each line, leaving others only a slice

Geoeconomic

How much of each listed line does the US buy, and could other markets take it?

“Other markets take only a slice of what Canada ships to the US today, since the US buys almost all of it.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 09. The relocation record shows Canadian cuts, not whole-plant moves to the US

Geoeconomic

Does the relocation record show whole plants moving to the US?

“Of 12 relocation announcements on record, 9 cut Canadian capacity and none moves a whole plant to the US.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 10. Post-duty trade data, not the undated review, is the trigger worth waiting for

Geoeconomic

Is the trade data or the CUSMA review the trigger worth waiting for?

“The review that could end the duty has no date, while the trade data that show who pays arrive on fixed days.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 13. Refunds from any court win go to the importer of record or its designee

Geoeconomic

Who receives the refund if a court strikes the duty?

“If a court strikes the Section 338 duty, the refund goes to whoever entered the goods, not to the firm that made them.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 11. On the worked line, a redirect breaks even after 9.9 months and a move with an unlisted input after 36

Geoeconomic

On the worked line, when does a redirect or a move break even?

“On the worked line, a redirect breaks even after 9.9 months and a move with an unlisted input after 36”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Addressed in: 16. Who pays the duty is not yet observed, and eight further limits bound this edition

Geoeconomic

What is not yet known about who pays the duty?

“No listed line had a trade month after the duty began, and no exporter or US buyer filing covered a period after 22 August 2026.”

The brief’s reading of the evidence; not a registered forecast.

Primary Canada Affected United States

Who is exposed · Strature analysis, not from the brief

US tariffs and Canada: the most exposed countries.

Ranked by their band on the published materiality lines, then by the number of channels in that band; the lead figure comes from our country reading where one is published. Strature research from public sources, not from this brief.

  1. High
    United StatesIn this briefSales to Canada, Supply from Canada (aluminium), Supply from Canada (crude), Supply from Canada (potash), Capital in Canada61.4% of US imports Supply from Canada (crude), 2025
  2. High
    MexicoCUSMA partner, US market rival (parts), US market rival (trucks)82% of US imports US market rival (trucks), 2025
  3. High
    ChinaSupply from Canada (canola), Supply from Canada (wheat), Diversification market94.8% of the country's imports of the good Supply from Canada (canola), 2025
  4. High
    CanadaIn this briefCapital in Canada, CUSMA partner72.3% of goods exports CUSMA partner, 2025
  5. High
    BrazilUS market rival (pulp)35.5% of US imports US market rival (pulp), 2025
Show 5 more exposed countries
  1. High
    NetherlandsCapital in CanadaC$182.9bn Capital in Canada, 2025
  2. High
    European Union (27)Diversification market5.52% of Canada's exports Diversification market, 2025
  3. High
    BelgiumSupply from Canada (potash)66.1% of the country's imports of the good Supply from Canada (potash), 2025
  4. High
    FranceSupply from Canada (iron ore)51.4% of the country's imports of the good Supply from Canada (iron ore), 2025
  5. High
    United KingdomCapital in CanadaC$108.1bn Capital in Canada, 2025
Since publication

What has changed since the research, dated.

Registered forecasts are never changed: they stay as issued and are scored as registered. Facts found after the research date are listed here with their date and source.

Registered with this edition, as issued

Each estimate is our estimate, scored when it resolves.

Forecasts registered with this edition, printed as issued; each estimate is our estimate, scored when it resolves
No.ForecastOur estimateIssuedResolvesStatus
F-0156the duty ends7%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open
F-0157partial relief23%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open
F-0158the duty lasts, US-bound sales hold25.2%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open
F-0159the duty lasts, US-bound sales cut28%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open
F-0160the duty lasts, US-bound sales collapse15.4%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open
F-0161the duty lasts, sales not yet measured1.4%Issued 30 Sep 2026Resolves 31 Dec 2026Open

No fact has been added since the research date.

No new forecast is issued with these facts; a new view would be a new, separately dated forecast.

For organisations

The full brief: free for organisations.

What the full brief contains

70 pages · Edition 1.0 · PDF · free for organisations

  1. Notice and summaries (3)
  2. The question, and how to read this brief
  3. Part I · How long the duty lasts (3 sections)
  4. Part II · Goods caught, and origin rules (2 sections)
  5. Part III · Customers and markets (2 sections)
  6. Part IV · Hold, redirect or move, and when? (4 sections)
  7. Part V · Who carries the duty, and relief (2 sections)
  8. Part VI · Options to consider (3 sections)
  9. Appendix and data annex
  10. Glossary and who's who
  11. Sources and method
  12. About Strature
  13. Terms of use and disclaimer
  14. Exhibits (26)

What the full brief adds: the complete edition behind the one-page sheet and the executive read, with its full reasoning, every exhibit and its sources.

The full brief is free during our introductory period, for organisations only. We do not supply it to individual consumers, to foreign governments or organisations they own or control, to parties named on sanctions lists, or in the countries and regions listed below. We rely on the declarations you make below; some requests are reviewed by our Principal before a download link is sent.

Every forecast in our published briefs, resolved and open: see the forecast register.

Request the full brief

You are requesting: Strature Brief Q-022, Edition 1.0, "The 50% duty, line by line: what it costs, and when Canadian exporters must decide".

Is your organisation located in Crimea, Sevastopol, or an area of the Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia or Kherson regions not controlled by the Government of Ukraine? (answer only if you chose Ukraine)
Declarations (each one is required)

These terms (version 1.3) replace the terms printed in the brief's last pages for this copy.

Sent by Strature Geopolitical Prospects & Strategy Inc., 375 University Avenue, Suite 3297, Toronto ON M5G 2J5, Canada, strature.net/contact. To stop, use the unsubscribe link in any email or the contact form.

We will email you a link to confirm your address and download the brief, or a note if we cannot supply it. Strature Geopolitical Prospects & Strategy Inc., 375 University Avenue, Suite 3297, Toronto ON M5G 2J5, Canada, contact@strature.net. See the privacy policy.

Interests

No position, no payment, no sponsor.

Strature and its principal hold no position in, and receive no payment from, any company or fund named in this brief. No issuer, fund, government or project sponsor paid for, commissioned the content of, or reviewed this brief.

Strature's principal, Milad Naeimi, follows a written trading policy: neither he nor Strature takes a position in any company, fund or listed security named in a brief from the start of drafting until 30 days after its publication, and the no-interest statement is re-confirmed before each edition.

Errors are corrected in a new edition or a dated reprint, and listed on the corrections page. Corrections · The Strature Briefs library

Questions about the series

Ask about the full brief, or suggest a question.

The answer to a suggested question is published to all readers.